Today's Today published 2 letters from its readers that are unhappy about MOE's explanation on heavy subsudies for future foreign talents studying in Singapore universities.
Before I voice out my own opinion as one of the foreign ex-students (now maybe considered as a foreign hopefully-with-talent), firstly I would like to apologize if it will offend some fellow Singaporeans. I acknowledge and appreciate the support (education, social and financial) given by Singapore (the people and the government) that enables me to pursue my higher education and career. Oh, and this one is a very long post
Ok, let me start. Mr. Rick Lim Say Kiong in his letter mentioned that the 'high' percentage of 20% in local universities that are occupied by foreigners has a link to complaints made by polytechnic graduates about not enough slots available for them. Personally, I do not have much to comment on this, but just curious whether the percentage is fixed, means that the goverment set the percentage first when admitting students, or just a derived number, means they get the number after the admission? If the 20% is gotten from the latter, I think it is fair enough as I believe the universities' admission criteria are not 'that' low and furthermore now they conduct entry examinations to filter only the best. I also know from friends that in recent years it is more difficult to be accepted to study here (for foreigners, at least from my country, Indonesia) compared to 6 - 7 years ago when I was admitted (which shows better students ought to be there now). Yes, I was just an average student. Anyway, in short this shows the fairness of the system, only they who are able to meet the standard and stand among the applicants, can enter, no matter whether you are a local or a foreigner.
Now, what if the system is the former? The government set the percentage first before the admission and try to fill up the slots available. Well, this does not really show the meritocracy 'ideology' adopted. But let's try to think the reason IF this is really the case. What I can think of is business. Business? Yes, business, money, green, moolah, whatever you call it. Education is a very lucrative business. With admitting a number of foreign students, you bring money in from overseas. From the very first time the students step into Singapore, the government is cashing in from them (airport fees from the airplane landings, also more gained if they are using Singapore airlines). Think about the lodging, the food, the transport, the books, entertainment and other students needs. They helped to create jobs (although they will be seen as a job grabber after they graduate, like me) and maintained when new batches of students come in. In other words, the government is quite smart in this money thing, so don't worry about it.
Ok, move on to the next item, un-talented talent? Well, simple, there tends to be bad apples among the good. It's just plain luck, that's why interviews are conducted before employing a person, again, whether local or foreigner. Nobody forces anyone to hire these bad apples. On the side note, people change. That's why some students who were good when they enter the school, transformed into slackers due to one issue or another (less parental monitoring???). Singaporean students should be lucky to have their parents nearby to monitor. Another thing, language does not really reflect one's intelligence, especially in technical fields. And for real, these students might only know their mother tounge and never use english before. Just imagine if a Singaporean who does not know Japanese studying in Japan. It's the same thing. To iterate, if you like him, then hire him. If you don't, then don't. Simple as that.
Next, Permanent Resident (PR) application. It is true indeed that we are offered PR as soon as we graduate. I was lucky my application was immediately approved after I landed on my job (I'm still with the same company until now). However, some also do not have that good fate as me. I personally know a few whose applications were rejected and have to work on employment pass. So, the approval is not by default as pictured by most people. The criteria for the approval I am not sure and better be clarified with Immigration and Checkpoint Authority (ICA).
Moving to the sensitive issues, money subsidization. I only have this: how come other big leagues universities do not differentiate the tuition fees for locals and foreigners? Both locals and foreigners have to pay the same fees, the difference only in bursaries.
The only irk comes from a letter by Lee Soon Bio mentioning that foreign students are guaranteed employment for three years. This statement shows how ignorant can some people be. The fact is that the 3 years are not a guaranteed employment, it is a bond that binds them to work for Singapore. Means, the students have to work with a Singapore based company for 3 years after graduation. It does not mean a guaranteed employment. If the student is unable to find any employment, he or she will have to repay the subsidy to the Singapore government. Bond-breakers will be discussed in other occassion, shall we? So, get the facts right!
Just a few last things. If your kid is not so bright and have to pay to (read: can) get a degree overseas, isn't it very fair compared to those whose kid is very bright but poor monetarily, denied place locally and unable to afford to send the kid overseas? This is what happened in other countries, just take a look at the neighbouring Malaysia and Indonesia. Do you know how difficult it is for Chinese to get entrance to the local non private university?
Finally, what is wrong with a diploma cert? Compared with an A lever graduate, personally I feel that a diploma holder who continue his study is better. Refer to my other post. I am so far believe (you can prove me wrong) that a person armed with diploma tends to be a better employee compared with those from JCs.
Now, will you pass the facts to the ignorants? Or should you whine again when the foreigner to local ratio is decreased causing only the topmost creme-de-la-crop foreigners admitted to the schools and causing the local kids lose again to them?
Technorati Tags: Singapore, education, school, university, foreigner, student